Should I Repair or Replace My Boiler?
If your boiler has packed in again, you are probably asking yourself: do I fix it one more time, or is it time to upgrade?
3 Key Questions to Ask Yourself
The truth is, the answer depends on your specific situation. This quick guide will help you weigh things up and figure out what is right for your home and budget.
1. How Old is It?
Under 8 Years: Repairs are usually worth it, especially if parts are available.
Over 10 Years: Efficiency drops significantly. Replacement is often smarter long-term.
2. Is it Reliable?
If this is the first fault, a repair makes sense.
If you are calling engineers out every winter, those costs add up fast. Stop patching and start planning.
3. Is it Efficient?
Old G-rated boilers waste fuel. A new A-rated Worcester Bosch can save up to £300 a year on energy bills.
The Cost Comparison
Sometimes the repair bill is just too high to justify on an old machine. Here is our rule of thumb:
❌ When to REPLACE
- The repair quote is over £400
- Parts are obsolete or hard to find
- The boiler is over 12 years old
- You plan to stay in the house long-term
✅ When to REPAIR
- The boiler is under 7 years old
- It is a simple part (e.g. fan or pump)
- You plan to move house soon
- You have a valid warranty
Still Not Sure? Let Us Take a Look
We will diagnose the fault and give you a fixed price to fix it. If it is uneconomical, we will tell you honestly.
Book a RepairGet a fixed price for a new boiler with up to 12 years guarantee. 0% Finance options available.
Get a QuoteWe also offer regular boiler servicing to keep your system running smoothly and catch issues before they turn into costly breakdowns.
Need Honest Advice?
We handle boiler repairs and replacements across Fife & The Lothians. Fairly priced, fast, and always honest.
Call 01383 660098Book an Engineer Online